| Year |
Coach |
School |
Category |
| 1989 |
Frank Saccala |
Glen Este (Cincinnati) |
Large Public School |
| 1990 |
Don Skelton |
Centerville |
Large Public School |
| 1993 |
Gale Fisk |
Bay (Bay Village) |
Small Public School |
| 1998 |
Roy Leatherbury |
Archbishop Alter (Kettering) |
Small Private School |
| 1998 |
Erik Ekis |
St. Francis De Sales (Columbus) |
Small Private School |
| 2007 |
Mike McLaughlin |
St. Ignatius (Cleveland) |
Private/Parochical School |
| 2008 |
Brian Stevens |
Centerville |
Large Public School |
| 2013 |
Scott Mollfenter |
Carroll (Dayton) |
Private/Parochical School |
| 2018 |
Steve Popp |
Beavercreek |
Large Public School |
| 2021 |
Mike McLaughlin |
St. Ignatius (Cleveland) |
Private/Parochical School |
| 2022 |
Pamela Malone |
Chagrin Falls |
Small Public School |
