| Year |
Division |
Player |
School |
| 1978 |
|
Tyson Bondurant |
Yellow Springs High School |
| 1979 |
|
Jim Becker |
North Olmsted High School |
| |
|
Cleve Miller |
Central-Hower High School |
| 1980 |
|
|
|
| 1981 |
|
Mark Pfister |
Brecksville High School |
| 1982 |
|
Brian Kohen |
Centerville High School |
| 1983 |
|
Reed Johnson |
Anderson High School |
| 1984 |
|
Tom O'Rouke |
North Olmsted |
| 1985 |
|
Joe Palmisano |
North Olmsted |
| 1986 |
AAA |
Laci Jalics |
Walsh Jesuit High School |
| |
AA-A |
Brad Petzinger |
Rocky River High School |
| 1987 |
AAA |
Tony Mastromatteo |
Walsh Jesuit High School |
| |
AA-A |
Mike Eason |
Indian Hill High School |
| 1989 |
AAA |
Bobby Focht |
Westerville South High School |
| |
AA-A |
Mike Pepe |
Canfield High School |
| 1990 |
I |
Wayne Lobring |
Anderson High School |
| |
II |
Ethan Cox |
Archbishop Alter High School |
| 1991 |
I |
Brandon Ward |
Westerville South High School |
| |
II |
Bobby Arthur |
Worthington Christian High School |
| 1991 |
I |
Nathan Fairchild |
Thomas Worthington High School |
| |
II |
Scott Downing |
Tipp City High School |
| 1992 |
I |
Tony Volpe |
Boardman High School |
| |
II |
Jesse Barrington |
Worthington Christian High School |
| 1993 |
I |
Dan Kindle |
Brecksville High School |
| |
II |
Andriy Shapowal |
Kenston |
| 1994 |
I |
Matt Daniel |
Worthington Kilbourne High School |
| |
II |
Gino Diguardi |
Archbishop Alter High School |
| 1995 |
I |
Doug Swaney |
Centerville High School |
| |
II |
|
|
| 1996 |
I |
|
|
| |
II |
|
|
| 1997 |
I |
Chris Moler |
Centerville High School |
| |
II |
Damon Butler |
Hawken High School |
| 1998 |
I |
Adam Capellone |
Walsh Jesuit High School |
| |
I |
Andrew Rutledge |
Thomas Worthington High School |
| |
II |
Matt Boswell |
Archbishop Hoban High School |
| 1999 |
I |
Bruce Murphy |
Strongsville High School |
| |
II |
Brian Carmany |
Hawken High School |
| 2000 |
I |
David Maier |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Mike Stoerkel |
Revere High School |
| |
III |
Lindsey Williams |
Columbus Academy |
| 2001 |
I |
Kevin Nugent |
Centerville High School |
| |
II |
Marc Burch |
Turpin High School |
| |
III |
Bobby Salas |
Worthington Christian High School |
| 2002 |
I |
Xavier Balc |
Hudson High School |
| |
II |
Brendan Murphy |
West Geauga High School |
| |
III |
DJ Catrow |
Springfield Catholic Central High School |
| 2003 |
I |
Xavier Balc |
Hudson High School |
| |
II |
Kenneth Willis |
Cardinal Mooney High School |
| |
III |
Kai Kaisguran |
Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy |
| 2004 |
I |
Gavin Blades |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Kenneth Willis |
Cardinal Mooney High School |
| |
III |
Duncan Silver-Nottle |
Yellow Springs High School |
| 2005 |
I |
Mark Blades |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Jeff Popella |
Carroll High School |
| |
III |
Ryan Hartman |
Greeneview High School |
| 2006 |
I |
Michael Lavric |
Gahanna Lincoln High School |
| |
II |
Stephen McGill |
Turpin High School |
| |
III |
Max Weston |
Worthington Christian High School |
| 2007 |
I |
Michael Green |
Strongsville High School |
| |
II |
Kit North |
Bishop Watterson High School |
| |
II |
Chris Barton |
Walsh Jesuit High School |
| |
III |
Nick Blevins |
Bloom Carroll High School |
| 2008 |
I |
Matt Wiet |
Worthington Kilbourne High School |
| |
II |
Matt Mason |
Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy |
| |
III |
Admir Suljevic |
Wickliffe High School |
| 2009 |
I |
Vaughn Spurrier |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Jacob Eganhouse |
St. Francis DeSales High School (Columbus) |
| |
III |
Eliot Browarsky |
Ottawa Hills High School |
| 2010 |
I |
William Trapp |
Gahanna Lincoln High School |
| |
II |
Alec Petro |
Bay High School |
| |
III |
Jack Thompson |
Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy |
| 2011 |
I |
Matt Foldsey |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Colin Romisher |
Revere High School |
| |
III |
Brett Elder |
Worthington Christian High School |
| 2012 |
I |
Tyler Sanda |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
I |
Sam Deroy |
Olentangy Liberty High School |
| |
II |
Brandon Taylor |
Revere High School |
| |
II |
Eric Lynch |
Bellbrook High School |
| |
III |
Federico Silva |
Western Reserve Academy |
| |
III |
Sam Bascom |
Madeira High School |
| 2013 |
I |
Jack Clark |
Mason High School |
| |
II |
Brandon Taylor |
Revere High School |
| |
III |
Christian Hay |
Summit Country Day High School |
| 2014 |
I |
Christopher Brennan |
Copley High School |
| |
II |
Noah Kummer |
Carroll High School |
| |
III |
Max Pochobradsky |
Seven Hills High School |
| 2015 |
I |
Stephen Milhoan |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Antonio Romanelli |
St. Francis DeSales High School (Columbus) |
| |
III |
Charlie Maciejewski |
Summit Country Day High School |
| 2016 |
I |
Stephen Milhoan |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Parker Simms |
Archbishop Alter High School |
| |
III |
Cameron Belle |
Summit Country Day High School |
| 2017 |
I |
Luke Kiley |
Coffman (Dublin) High School |
| |
II |
Hector Gomez |
St. Francis DeSales High School (Columbus) |
| |
III |
Harrison Schertzinger |
Summit Country Day High School |
| 2018 |
I |
Noah Boffo |
New Albany High School |
| |
II |
Cade Gergye |
Bay High School (Bay Village) |
| |
II |
Cristian Gomez |
St. Francis DeSales High School (Columbus) |
| |
III |
Josh Kidder |
Archbold High School |
| 2019 |
I |
Parker Csiszar |
Medina High School |
| |
II |
Kyle Cusimano |
Bay High School (Bay Village) |
| |
III |
John Kight |
Ottawa Hills High School |
| 2020 |
I |
Luciano Pechota |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Brock Pickett |
Bay High School (Bay Village) |
| |
III |
Luke Brothers |
Mariemont High School |
| 2021 |
I |
Luciano Pechota |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Trevor Rorabaugh |
Revere High School |
| |
III |
Marco Valentic |
Kirtland High School |
| 2022 |
I |
Nolan Spicer |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Gus Peacock |
Wyoming High School |
| |
III |
Eli Eyrich |
Yellow Springs High School |
| 2023 |
I |
Bradley Poppell |
Archbishop Moeller High School |
| |
II |
Dylan Halm |
Revere High School |
| |
III |
Sanny Qwusu-Sarfo |
Worthington Christian High School |
| 2024 |
I |
Marty McLaughlin |
St. Ignatius High School |
| |
II |
Londen Sears |
New Albany High School |
| |
III |
Connor Wilkes |
Indian Hill High School |
| |
IV |
Grant Keilin |
Beachwood High School |
| |
V |
Maddox Andrea |
United Local High School |