| Year |
Name |
School |
| 1988 |
Ben Belleman |
Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy (Cuyahoga Falls) |
| 1989 |
Chuck Ausman |
Oak Hills (Cincinnati) |
| 1990 |
Tiho Teisl |
Gilmour Academy (Gates Mills) |
| 1991 |
Steve Rand |
Grove City |
| 1992 |
Tim Patterson |
Hudson |
| 1993 |
Dale Conley |
Western Reserve Academy (Hudson) |
| 1994 |
George Bell |
Wooster |
| 1995 |
Beth Murphy |
Jackson |
| 1996 |
John Johnson |
Revere (Richfield) |
| 1997 |
Dave Thomas |
Lorain Catholic |
| 1998 |
Tom Mackar |
Mentor |
| 1999 |
Pat Gillespie |
Rocky River |
| 2000 |
Bob Dean |
Hudson |
| 2001 |
Joe Garisto |
Northwestern |
| 2002 |
Gale Fisk |
Bay (Bay Village) |
| 2003 |
Neil Baasten |
St. Thomas Aquinas |
| 2004 |
John Scramling |
Brush (Lyndhurst) |
| 2005 |
Gene DeWeese |
Coffman (Dublin) |
| 2006 |
Mark Czubik |
Kalida |
| 2007 |
John Sabol |
Barberton |
| 2008 |
Tim Carney |
Napoleon |
| 2009 |
Mike Weihrauch |
Ottawa-Glandorf |
| 2010 |
Mario Gerhardt |
Chargin Falls |
| 2011 |
Mike Lally |
Twinsburg |
| 2012 |
Sean Sullivan |
Cleveland Heights |
| 2013 |
Paul Boll |
Wheelersburg |
| 2014 |
Tom Krupitzer |
Swanton |
| 2015 |
Mike McLaughliin |
St. Ignatius (Cleveland) |
| 2016 |
Robert Dougherty |
Bay (Bay Village) |
| 2017 |
John Orozco |
Toledo Christian |
| 2018 |
Michael Householder |
Firestone (Akron) |
| 2019 |
Dave Antal |
Copley |
| 2020 |
Todd Morris |
Marietta |
| 2021 |
Brian Green |
Beachwood |
| 2022 |
Ben Dotson |
Brunswick |
| 2023 |
Kevin Zerbey |
Rocky River |
| 2024 |
Brian Nelson |
Cincinnati Christian |
